Adobe Flash Player 10.3  -  Bug 3059118

Created on Thursday, December 1, 2011

Login for more options

Title

[Platform_Windows]Nested timeline audio plays when jumped with gotoAndStop

Description

Problem Description:

I develop games that contain a lot of character animation, working with a lot of animators and designers. This often means having different 'scenes' that consist of movieclips on the main timeline. So I might have a frame label "scene1", and on the stage will be a movieclip called 'scene1' that contains nested content for scene 1. On some user generated event I might then skip to frame scene2, that is set up in the same way.
These scenes will often contain character movieclips that will have labelled keyframes set up along their timeline that house nested movieclips of different animatino states (eg, idle, walk, jump, etc). These animations may often require carefully timed audio at some point in their duration. which requires using timeline sound.
If I make the timeline jump past one of these scenes (eg jump from scene 1 to scene 3, passing scene 2 on the way) the nested movieclips play continously, ignoring any 'stop()' commands that might be present, and playing all the sounds on the timeline.


Steps to Reproduce:

See above, or attached example

Actual Result:

Sounds play from nested movieclips

Expected Result:

No sounds should play

Any Workarounds:

The only workaround is to avoid using timeline sound altogether.
To be frank, this problem has existed since flash CS3. I have just downloaded the demo of flash cs5.5 and it is still not fixed. Needless to say I am pretty cross about this! We have been unable to use timeline sound for years now, so you have cost us so much extra time wasted working around the issue by rigging up elaborate systems for playing all sound through code - it is infuriating!
..

Test Configuration

*********INFO BOARD*********
If bug is set as ToTrack or Closed as Defer, it means we have reproduced the problem, but unfortunately, it does not get high enough priority to address in our current release. We track follow up messages and votes info for each bug. Please help us to vote the bug if you run into the same issue, let us know the impact for your development and business. Thank you.
********************************
1, For issues related to Video/Audio/Rendering, please upload your system info file.
http://kb2.adobe.com/cps/839/cpsid_83952.html
2, It will be always helpful if you can provide code snippet that repro the issue.

App Language(s) ALL
OS Language(s) ALL
Platform(s) Win XP All
Browser(s) Unspecified

Notes (6)

  • Cptn_Uncanny

    10:16:40 PM GMT+00:00 Aug 15, 2013

    This is still a problem for me, and I'm amazed that it's not fixed.
    Not being able to control sound (reliably) via the timeline is not acceptable. It's just not feasible sometimes to do it through code, and it would be nice to rely on the timeline.
    This is a serious issue if you are making animations, and I keep resorting to working around this issue with every version of Flash. Please fix it.

  • alex.harrison

    1:34:57 AM GMT+00:00 Sep 11, 2012

    Incidentally I just got around to testing this in flash cs6 (on a mac) and the bug is still there...

  • jendabek

    4:29:42 AM GMT+00:00 May 30, 2012

    It is quite serious bug and causes it is not possible to use timeline at all in some cases.
    Please fix it as soon as possible! It is very long time since it was reported.

  • Yang Liu

    7:12:57 PM GMT+00:00 Dec 13, 2011

    Thanks for your reporting. We could reproduce your issue.

  • alex.harrison

    3:56:15 AM GMT+00:00 Dec 1, 2011

    Another work around is to put a stop on the first frame of the 'scene' movieclip and shunt all the content along to frame 2. Then the playhead can skip over the scene without its content playing. But this is a big hassle because in AS3, when I call gotoAndStop I can't immediately access the movieclips that are on the timeline at the new frame. I'd have to add an event listener to wait until the frame is ready after calling gotoAndStop, before trying to access them, which would make my code needlessly convoluted and hard to follow.

  • alex.harrison

    3:26:05 AM GMT+00:00 Dec 1, 2011

    Please fix this - it has literally been years now!

Duplicate ID
Reported By alex.harrison

Status

State Open
Status ToTrack
Reason

Importance

Priority 2-Medium
Frequency All users will encounter
Failure Type Incorrectly Functioning
Product Area Audio

Build

Found In Build 10.3.181.14
Fixed In Build

Attachments (1)

Votes (3)

  • patach

    2:24:21 AM GMT+00:00 Jan 6, 2013

    The same problem on CS6. This is frustrating to have to have workarounds for this sound problem.

  • jendabek

    4:36:48 AM GMT+00:00 May 30, 2012

    I am forced to completely avoid using Timeline in some cases and my projects is unnecessarily complicated because cannot see the content visually.
    It was reported years ago and it is still not fixed even in beta FP11.

  • Oldes Huhuman

    12:50:25 AM GMT+00:00 Jan 24, 2012

    This bug is really annoying and was one of the main problems when we have been rewriting our project from AS2 to AS3.

Your session has expired! Click to login
Current form data will be preserved

Cancel